Come thrive with the Hiiv | beehiiv Community Icon

Strategies to Address Beehiiv Smart Warming Issues

May 05, 2025

Reading time: 1 minute

Getting hammered pretty hard by Beehiiv smart warming - dumped completely onto our own domain after a trickle smart warming period over a few months. Any thoughts on how to get this adjusted from the beehiiv team? I've searched in this slack and seen a few similar comments so hopefully it solves itself

8 comments

Conor
·
·
hey William! thanks for your patience here.
Conor
·
·
just to make sure I'm on the right page:
you were on smart warming
smart warming finished after a few months and you transitioned to your custom domain
but now you're seeing some deliverability issues?
Any specific metrics that you see suffering?
Conor
·
·
just want to make sure i give you the right guidance here. thanks for your work
William F.
·
·
Hey Conor thanks for the help! Yes, we were on smart warming for longer than I anticipated. About 2 weeks ago, we rolled off it to our own domain. However, smart warming with Beehiiv was moving pretty slow compared to our growth rate. Our sending volume grew from around 10K to 40K within 8-10 weeks. At the height of it, Beehiiv dropped us off of its domain to our own. Now we are seeing open rates under 10% even as we've decreased volumes to our highest open rate segments.
William F.
·
·
here's what I can see
Conor
·
·
cool cool. thanks for sharing that. Smart warming can only proceed on sends, but it does sound like something might not have gone as well as it could have. to best diagnose, could you please reach out to the Support team? they'll be able to dig in and see if it makes sense to do some more warming, or maybe just some list cleaning. tl;dr - there is def stuff we can do here to improve your open rate and make sure things are going well
William F.
·
·
thanks for the reply - yea been asking for help via email but the replies have been pretty slow so thought I would try here. we'll try some more list cleanings for the next send and see if that works.
Conor
·
·
sounds great. im sure the team will get back to you asap (deliverability can take some digging). but either way, we got you!

Email 101

Strategies to Address Beehiiv Smart Warming Issues

William F.

May 05, 2025

Reading time: 1 minute

8 comments

Conor
·
·
hey William! thanks for your patience here.
Conor
·
·
just to make sure I'm on the right page:
you were on smart warming
smart warming finished after a few months and you transitioned to your custom domain
but now you're seeing some deliverability issues?
Any specific metrics that you see suffering?
Conor
·
·
just want to make sure i give you the right guidance here. thanks for your work
William F.
·
·
Hey Conor thanks for the help! Yes, we were on smart warming for longer than I anticipated. About 2 weeks ago, we rolled off it to our own domain. However, smart warming with Beehiiv was moving pretty slow compared to our growth rate. Our sending volume grew from around 10K to 40K within 8-10 weeks. At the height of it, Beehiiv dropped us off of its domain to our own. Now we are seeing open rates under 10% even as we've decreased volumes to our highest open rate segments.
William F.
·
·
here's what I can see
Conor
·
·
cool cool. thanks for sharing that. Smart warming can only proceed on sends, but it does sound like something might not have gone as well as it could have. to best diagnose, could you please reach out to the Support team? they'll be able to dig in and see if it makes sense to do some more warming, or maybe just some list cleaning. tl;dr - there is def stuff we can do here to improve your open rate and make sure things are going well
William F.
·
·
thanks for the reply - yea been asking for help via email but the replies have been pretty slow so thought I would try here. we'll try some more list cleanings for the next send and see if that works.
Conor
·
·
sounds great. im sure the team will get back to you asap (deliverability can take some digging). but either way, we got you!